Club Car
Carryall 500
Premium performance, legendary reliability
🏆 Our Pick
8.3
★★★★⯨
Out of 10.0
Community rating: 4.9/5
Community rating: 4.9/5
Price From
$8,500
Range
35–55 miles
Top Speed
19–25 mph
Street Legal
Available
Strengths
Strong build quality
Good range for the price
Established brand support
Solid warranty coverage
Drawbacks
Can be pricier than alternatives
Dealer coverage varies by region
Star EV
Workmaster 60
Commercial-grade electric vehicles
8.1
★★★★⯨
Out of 10.0
Community rating: 4.4/5
Community rating: 4.4/5
Price From
$8,500
Range
35–50 miles
Top Speed
19–23 mph
Street Legal
Available
Strengths
Competitive pricing
Modern features
Growing support network
Good value proposition
Drawbacks
Newer brand with less history
Range slightly shorter
Resale value still establishing
GCR Expert Summary
Club Car Carryall vs Star EV Workmaster — utility and commercial-grade golf carts compared for fleet, resort, and industrial use.
Our evaluation covers six weighted categories: performance, comfort, technology, value, reliability, and resale value. The Club Car Carryall 500 earns our top pick designation based on this comprehensive scoring. Both carts are excellent choices. See the detailed spec table and score breakdown above for specific strengths in your priority categories.
Score Breakdown
Our Verdict: Club Car Carryall 500 Wins
Both carts are excellent choices. See the detailed spec table and score breakdown above for specific strengths in your priority categories.
8.3 / 10 — Club Car
8.1 / 10 — Star EV
Full Spec Comparison
| Specification | Club Car Carryall 500 | Star EV Workmaster 60 |
|---|---|---|
| Performance & Power | ||
| Motor / Drive | 48–72V AC Brushless | 48–72V AC Brushless |
| Battery | Lithium standard or optional | Lithium standard or optional |
| Range | 35–55 milesBest | 35–50 miles |
| Top Speed | 19–25 mph | 19–23 mph |
| Payload Capacity | 800–1,000 lbs | 800–950 lbs |
| Seating | 4 | 4 |
| Curb Weight | 800–950 lbs | 780–900 lbs |
| Warranty | 2–4 year limitedBest | 2–3 year limited |
| Street Legal / LSV | Available | Available |
| Charger | On-board | On-board |
| Brand Info | ||
| Founded | 1958 | 2003 |
| Origin | Augusta, GA | Conway, SC |
| Price Range | $8,500 – $18,000+ | $8,500 – $16,000 |
| Community Rating | 4.9/5 ★ | 4.4/5 ★ |
Best For Each Use Case
Neighborhood
Club CarGolf Course
Club CarBest Value
Star EVBattery Life
Club CarFrequently Asked Questions
Which cart is better for neighborhood use?+
Both models are well-suited for neighborhood use. Your choice should be based on seating needs, desired top speed, and whether you need LSV street-legal certification.
Which has the better battery?+
Both offer lithium battery options that provide excellent range and longevity. Lithium packs typically last 8–10 years with proper care.
Are either of these carts street legal?+
Both brands offer LSV-certified configurations that meet FMVSS standards for street-legal low-speed vehicles. Check with your local dealer for state-specific requirements.
Which is easier to maintain?+
Electric golf carts from both brands have minimal maintenance requirements — primarily checking tire pressure, cleaning battery terminals, and occasional brake inspections.
Can I finance either cart?+
Yes. Both brands work with third-party financing companies. Use our Golf Cart Loan Calculator to estimate monthly payments.
